Bay Rum Collection
- Thread starter No1Up
- Start date
Nice collection!
I've got the Ogallala Bay Rum with Sandalwood. I like it, but it's not what I consider a bay rum. Someone here on B&B described the Ogallala as a "cowboy" bay rum. I'm not sure what that means...last I looked there were no bays in Nebraska...unless one considers "bay" horses....
I've got the Ogallala Bay Rum with Sandalwood. I like it, but it's not what I consider a bay rum. Someone here on B&B described the Ogallala as a "cowboy" bay rum. I'm not sure what that means...last I looked there were no bays in Nebraska...unless one considers "bay" horses....
Great pics!
And your favorite is?
Thanks for sharing. I have some Captain's Choice and St. John's but none of the rest. I didn't realize PAA made so many!
Mine is very simple: CC Bay Rum & Co9T AS, Oglalla cologne. I'm dissatisfied with the Oglalla due to its clove content, but it's OK. Still hoping to find a pure bay rum cologne.
- Thread starter
- #8
PAA quickly became my favorite aftershave/cologne maker. I love everything I bought so far.
My favorite Bay rum would be hard to say, I can tell you Ogalla is out! I love Saint johns island spice, and bay rum. A VERY close second, if not right up there is a a few dashes of Cat O 9 Tails, with a drop or 2 of PAA Bay rum, this makes the Captains choice last longer, like 8 hours longer! lol VERY cool Bay rums.
My favorite Bay rum would be hard to say, I can tell you Ogalla is out! I love Saint johns island spice, and bay rum. A VERY close second, if not right up there is a a few dashes of Cat O 9 Tails, with a drop or 2 of PAA Bay rum, this makes the Captains choice last longer, like 8 hours longer! lol VERY cool Bay rums.
- Thread starter
- #9
My wife LOVES me when I Use the PAA OTTRA
How do you like the Phoenix artisan Otra?
Ogallala is my favorite. Last week I stopped in Ogallala, NE and picked some up. I got a big bottle of AS and some of their body and shave soaps. I'm headed back that way in a month and will probably buy a lot more.
Nice line-up.
- Thread starter
- #13
I should mention that the Ogallay Bay Rum is ok, but the other stuff was just terrible. I like the island kind of spice though.
Saint Johns has to be the winner followed closely by PAA bay rum. trailing behind a bit is Co9T. They all have their own take on Bay rum, so they are all worth getting... PAA Bay Rum etches them all out with the longest lasting scent.
Saint Johns has to be the winner followed closely by PAA bay rum. trailing behind a bit is Co9T. They all have their own take on Bay rum, so they are all worth getting... PAA Bay Rum etches them all out with the longest lasting scent.
My collection includes 2 from barber supply houses: Master Well Comb, and Stephens. I also like Pinaud St. John's but my women hate it. They say I smell like pumpkin pie. My favorite is Krampert's Finest accadian spice.
- Thread starter
- #15
I like pinaud, I have it here somewhere.
I forgot to mention Superior 70. It is a high alcohol bay rum with the truest bay flavor I have.
Here's mine:
Avon
Bootlegger's
What's that? My original Bay Rum looks a little low? No worries, I've got a refill.
Master, Pinaud, and the Rexall bottle is full of Superior 70
Purepac, CC North and Sandalwood (I'm pretty sure there's some BR in their base), and Burt's Bees Balm.
Avon
Bootlegger's
What's that? My original Bay Rum looks a little low? No worries, I've got a refill.
Master, Pinaud, and the Rexall bottle is full of Superior 70
Purepac, CC North and Sandalwood (I'm pretty sure there's some BR in their base), and Burt's Bees Balm.
- Thread starter
- #19
What?! No saint johns?!
Thats criminal!
Thats criminal!
Sorry, that's way out of my price range. If it's more expensive than CC, I'll pass. I like the cheap stuff better anyway. Bootlegger's is my favorite bay rum of all.
