Good luck finding the shaving cream in stores. Most have been sold out for a few weeks now, and they're not sure when they'll get more. I hope they have it in stock for you.
BTW, B&BW often runs "Buy 3 get one free", and "$10 off of a $40 purchase". If you like C.O. Bigelow, you can almost always get something for nothing. SWMBO has a part time job there. Individual stores do not do their own ordering. They stock whatever corporate sends them, so they do not know when products will arrive, with the exception of the next promotion.
I highly recommend the peppermint body wash (Not for sensitive skin, watch out around the starfish pucker). It's very cooling, and smells great.
BB&W is also releasing a new line of products. Check out the stuff called "Oak" I got a sample of the body wash a couple of weeks ago. I think the aftershave comes out this weekend. It kind of smells like cedar.