Barbershop may as well be called Any Fragrance at this point. Some of the ones actually called Barbershop, Like Soap Commander Honor which I love, smell absolutely nowhere near what the Stirling smells like. And then oddly enough, something not called Barbershop, like Proraso Green for example, reminds me of an actual Italian-owned barbershop my dad frequented when I was a kid on the south side of Chicago. Feel free to buy/try anything called Barbershop, get scents all over the map, and then expect some random scent to remind you of a Barbershop, if you've ever been in one, of course.