Tabac is a very polarizing scent; you either love it or hate it. For that reason I would recommend finding it somewhere you can smell it first. I bought it scent unsmelled and did not like it. I'll probably put it on the BST soon because I have a nearly full bottle and puck since I only used it twice. (the soap does perform great though)
Stirling is great and I love Mudder Focker from RazoRock.