FWIW I have used 8 different TOBS creams including the Organic, none of them cause me any problems and I have skin that often reacts badly to other shave soaps and creams. The only TOBS which bothered my skin was the Grapefruit, and that was years ago.
Also Mitchell’s Wool Fat has never bothered me, if you want a different brand.
Finding what worked for my skin took time and many unsuccessful purchases, good luck
Have you tried TOBS Avocado- check the ingredients but it may work for you. The Avocado isn't a strong scent, smells like cucumbers to me but some folks say cut grass YMMV
Thanks ; I've tried many TOOBS , including Avocado which I like , and many other creams and soaps, from other makers .
The Taylors Organic is my favorite . It gets the job done without getting in the way and leaves my skin in good condition , so that I'm "Lookin' Good , Feelin" Good" .
I just ordered the Taylors Natural and then found the organic at the regular non gouge price which also included free shipping , so ordered that .
AFAIK , the Taylors Organic regularly sells for $22.99 and is currently available from many vendors .
A third party vendor on Amazon , who shows it's in stock is selling for $32.99 .