Wife loves Gillette Coolwave on me (glass bottle, made in France). Scent is similar to the Gillette AS gel which comes in the small blue plastic bottle. She pretty much goes nuts over Coolwave.
She tolerates all the others (Brut, Skin Bracer, Clubman, etc) but can't stand Osage Rub. No big deal for me, as I prefer to use OR on my hair while showering instead of using it as an AS. For me, adding menthol crystals to my favorite AS is preferable to using OR so I'm good to go in that regard.
The wife goes shave shopping with me, so everything that gets brought home has already been given the nod. The stuff that seems be asked for most as of lately are -
Soap commander - grapefruit, passion
Maggards - limes and bergamot
RazoRock - original aftershave wax
Ogallala - Bay rum and vanilla (which we were given and just received today, good lookin peterwinkle!)
AV Ice Blue
AV Musk
Skin Bracer
Bootlegger's Perfecto
Bootlegger's El Dorado
Tabac
Shulton Old Spice Fresh Lime
British Sterling
Vintage Avon Mesmerize