This one. Mild sandalwood. Gone within an hour, at least for me.
Or anything else that WON'T compete or clash with the snuggle juice, which is Bois Du Portugal. I guess I've never understood the need to double up or match aftershaves with colognes. I view aftershaves as medicinal and skin toning in nature; let the cologne do its job on its own.
I agree with @Black Adder. BdP smells so great on its own, why would you want to use an after shave? I used to try and match AS with my fragrance of the day. Not only did I finally decide it was futile trying to match AS with fragrances, I gave up using AS all together. I never used AS until I joined B&B and I have been shaving for 50+ years. Four years later I'm back to no AS again.
I'm not aware of any aftershave that would pair with BdP. I personally would go with an unscented aftershave and let BdP do its thing on its own. Why mess with perfection?