After some experimentation, I've come to the conclusion that Prairie Creations soap makes me break out. I also have my suspicions that VDH deluxe does too. So, I'm thinking it is the tallow in the PC, and the shea butter in the VDH. Are there any soaps like VDH deluxe except for the lack of shea butter. It can't have palm oil or coconut oil as a main ingredient as those soaps don't agree with my skin. It looks like VDH select meets that requirement. Are there any others like that? Does VDH select lather the same as the deluxe?