I've quickly become addicted to the Sienna shave soap, so I picked up a few bars of the bath soap. I'll also agree that it's not exactly the same as the shave soap, scent wise.
Does an excellent job of leaving a squeaky clean, no residue Blaine.
A tad expensive, but... as I said, I'm addicted. So it's money well spent.
I love these C&E soaps too. I was lucky enough to find several assorted mens C&E soap bars at a TJ Maxx a few months back for $2.99 each! I made a couple of trips and probably purchased every bar they had which was about 15 or so. Got the Sienna, Nomad and Sandalwood bars. I have enjoyed each one of them. They lather up well and the scent lasts quite a while for a soap. I found the soaps to be very moisturizing.
I picked up a box of the Sienna bath soap from C&E. $20 for a box of three bars (5.3 oz. each).
The Sienna performs great as a bath soap. The scent is almost exactly like the shaving soap (maybe a touch more leather); the bars last for a fair amount of time (two weeks so far on one bar); and it does what bath soap is supposed to do.
The soap lather is fine. Nothing to write home about. It's a vegetable soap (with vitamin E added), so I don't expect heaps of lather.
Afterward, there is a light scent of the Sienna left on the skin. It's very light, it wears off in a few hours, and it hasn't interfered with any of my colognes. Actually, it seems to enhance them a bit. It made a noticeable difference (compared to basic deodorant soap) in how Penhaligon's scents performed.
The packaging is fine. Three individually wrapped bars in a slider box.
I'm really pleased with this soap and will be using it as regularly as the budget will allow.