I've never tried this solo, but like the others have said, it works great with the CAR conditioner. Scent is good, but not too strong. Definitely refreshing. I find all of CAR's products to be top notch.
I recently started using CAR's whole Hydrolast system and have been impressed with everything. The tonic and AS conditioner are definately outstanding products. I had been using the peppermint AS alone for a few months but coupled with the Lime tonic, really really nice!
I can't really compare it to any others, like QED, as I haven't tried them yet. But so far I definately recommend this
Now - while I do not think on its own this product is anything too wonderous, when coupled with CAR A/S moisture cream, it is a dream come true.
First - let me say, the scent on these sprays is simply delightful. Really original and "out there." The Summer Sage is incredibly soothing, the Lime is invigorating and the Frankincense/Orange is just... well... superb!
Really a nice pick me up - and I would highly recommend.
I do think it is important to point out however - that I personally feel QED DaVinci water is a superior product, as it has the ability to assist an aftershave/moisture cream, and it can also stand on its own. I also love the scent of DaVinci water, and feel it might be a touch better. With that said BOTH are nice products and have their specific niches.