To date I've not used a synthetic that matches natural hair. I'm most comfortable using my Silvertip or Best badger brushes. This is about on par with my Black Badger brush as far as backbone and feel. A tad scratchy, but not bad. This has produced great lather with Arko and Williams. My only complaint is the horse smell. It's very different from badger funk, not quite as rodent smelling, more like a farm or stable scent. But it's very strong. I've tried all sorts of methods to remove the funk and it's dropped in intensity about 50% but it's still there.