I tried the ones from PAA a few months ago and they're what I use now. They're pretty effective for me.
Use the New Bravo Sierra deodorant from Target. Was tested on 1000+ special forces group. The cost is 8.99 for 3.2 ounces, but 5% goes back to the military. The deodorant smell manly and goes on smooth, with no stickiness and I don't think this will crumble like most do. I've been using mine for a week now and it lasts all day without reapplying. Give it a try with a money back quarantee.....Good luck!!Old Spice deodorant stick is my go to. If you sweat a lot then use an alum block under your arms first, then slap on the Spice. I did buy some Brut deodorant spray but my god it burnt my armpits so bad it felt like actual fire. I had to wash it off immediately and only use it now to spray directly onto my clothes. I do also use the Brut 'splash on' in the tall bottle, it says it's for the whole body so i use the alum block on my pits and chuck on a slosh of the splash for that extra Brut-y stink!
I don't see why you can't use any aftershave as a deodorant, coupled with alum you're scented and your sweat glands are toned down.