I've only had TOBS sandalwood and grapefruit, but I did not care for sandalwood at all. Good thing I only got the 75ml tube. With that experience in mind, I gambled on a full tub of grapefruit, and it's the best smelling shave product in my small collection. It's outstanding, a pleasant surprise!
I don't know if they still make it, because I didn't see it on maggard when I just looked, but "shaving shop" is awesome!!!
Also eton college, jermyn street and luxury are awesome too.