I don't mean the lather becomes lije you say, just much betterAll one needs is to paint a thin film of wet soap on the skin to sit for couple of minutes to get a great shave. What matters is for the lather not to be dry and sitting on top of your face instead of sticking to your skin. The thick Santa beard with amazing wet elastic peaks and high density is purely for show.
I generally bowl lather as my face is too sensitive to withstand face lathering, except with the softest of brushes. My criteria for a good soap is that I should be able to achieve a lather free of larger bubbles in less than 60 seconds of vigorous agitation in the bowl. I have found that some harder soaps take more than 60 seconds, a few even more than two minutes. I won't use a soap that cannot produce a great lather in two minutes. I do not have the patience to use a soap that takes more than two minutes to produce a great lather.
There is one video on YouTube of a guy who spent twelve minutes lathering Williams Mug Soap. He probably did not need to go quite that long, but Williams does take longer to lather than nearly any other soap.
This. I can get by with ok lather with a DE. It has to be like this for straights or my face will suffer.All one needs is to paint a thin film of wet soap on the skin to sit for couple of minutes to get a great shave. What matters is for the lather not to be dry and sitting on top of your face instead of sticking to your skin. The thick Santa beard with amazing wet elastic peaks and high density is purely for show.
I bowl lather as well, and after some trial and error, I usually get a very decent "tight bubble" creamy lather within 45-60 seconds. I had trouble initially, but that turned out to be because of my hard water situation and using natural bristle brushes. When I switched to synthetic, it was like "pop"! I also pretty much use only tallow soaps.
Oh, and one other trick I learned was when I take my shower I put the brush in hot water and put about a palms worth of hot water on my soap to bloom. BUT, when I get out of the shower and get ready to lather, I pour out the water in my bowl and take the remaining "soapy" water from the bloom and pour that tiny amount into the bottom of my bowl to use as a starter when I make my lather. It's amazing how much such a tiny thing like that made such a huge difference.
I also don't use a standard lathering bowl or scuttle. I use a large stoneware bowl I bought at WalMart that I took and sanded out the bottom to create a bit more friction for when I make my lather. It's slightly larger and deeper than a standard cereal bowl and is deep enough that my lather does not spill out. I have to make a good deal of lather as I head shave as well.
Your method sounds a lot like the one I use for lathering. It works on all but the most difficult soaps.