I have the following; Aqua Velva Ice Blue, CVS Razor (their take on AV), Lucky Tiger Aspen, Master Blue, Booster Polar Ice, and Floid Blue. What is neat is that out of the bottle, none of these smell like any other. Most have some menthol in varying amounts. However, they all fade away to a some sort of powdery finish. I plan on wearing each of these for consecutive days to establish a pecking order. They are all enjoyable, but right now I would be unaware how they compare rated 1 thru 6.