Would like to know out of the 4, Haslinger, Tabac, Stirling and MWF what would the top performer be, not looking at post shave as I use a moisturizer with sunscreen just looking at which one performs the best.
Anthony
Anthony
4 pack
- Thread starter Anthony88
- Start date
Do you have soft water?
Use a synthetic brush?
If so, all are top. Tabac is not a favorite of mine, tho.
Use a synthetic brush?
If so, all are top. Tabac is not a favorite of mine, tho.
MWF - but needs to be used regularly or it gets sulky.
Tabac gives perfect lather almost instantly in any water. I haven't tried Haslinger.
- Thread starter
- #5
Tell me about it! Two days and it has cracks to the center of the Earth ... but it IS awesome.
AA
Haslinger is miles ahead of the other three, IMO.
Interesting question. Two (Has and MWF) are virtually unscented ... Tabac; scent is strong love/hate and Stirling (depends which: many).
All four are very, very good performers. MWF, little harder to use.
AA
Haslinger gives perfect lather almost instantly in any water. I haven't tried Tabac.
(I love MWF and think Stirling is excellent too - can't get past the smell of Tabac)
Maybe one of the Haslinger soaps in their lineup is close to being unscented, but Schafmilch smells quite heavily of baby powder.
No experience with Haslinger. The other three are all good (I just tried Stirling and love it).
Tabac - Excellent lather with a polarizing scent. I personally can't stand it and I really tried to like it.
MWF - Lather requires a little more work than the others. Has the best post-shave feel of all.
Stirlilng - Lots of scents and great lather.
Tabac - Excellent lather with a polarizing scent. I personally can't stand it and I really tried to like it.
MWF - Lather requires a little more work than the others. Has the best post-shave feel of all.
Stirlilng - Lots of scents and great lather.
all four are excellent soaps, but I think Haslinger might be the least expensive.
Tabac. Or Haslinger
Tabac
I’ve got a freezer full!!
I’ve got a freezer full!!
I have 25 pucks and 17 sticks. Tabac does that to people.
Noted, thanks. I've only used the sage and the marigold, though I have that schafmilk one ...
AA
I’ve used all 4, & Haslinger Schafmilch edges out Tabac in my humble opinion.
I’ve owned all 4
Tough call, but Haslinger would be my top pick. I really like the Sage scent.
I do really like MWF, but it’s super finicky for me and a pain to get a perfect lather
Tabac performance is great but the scent is seriously awful
Stirling has great slickness and has some cool scents.
Tough call, but Haslinger would be my top pick. I really like the Sage scent.
I do really like MWF, but it’s super finicky for me and a pain to get a perfect lather
Tabac performance is great but the scent is seriously awful
Stirling has great slickness and has some cool scents.
I’ve only used stirrings out of the 4 it’s is a great soap a good scents I just can’t bring myself to try tabac I hate the tobacco scents and some of the stronger ones I smelled even nauseate me so for the price it’s just not worth trying if I could get it in a different scent or unscented I would probably try it I’ve not seen anything negative about it’s performance haslinger and mwf are on my to try list
