Nivea Sensitive in the white tube, just the best.
Body shop maca root old formula, I have not tried the new formula yet but it should be as good.
I have three full tubs of the old formula and about half of another one. I am looking forward to giving the new formula a try!I have sensitive skin and just got the new formula Maca Root shaving cream. It’s fantastic. Body Shop will make you a sample if you want to try it first. Also their 40% off sale is on now so the price is around ten bucks.
I also have sensitive skin, the products that work very well for me are;
TOBS Organic & Aloe
Nivea Sensitive cream
Bulldog sensitive cream (Very good for the skin, but its brushless and wont lather)
Arko sticks
Palmolive cream and sticks
MWF (Sold cheaper as Kent soap, be careful of the lanolin)
Real Shaving Company cream
Proraso red, soap & cream.
Edwin jagger aloe (Expensive for what it is really)
Monsavon
Be careful with products billed as "sensitive" such as TOBS Jermyn St and Proraso white, the TOBS is quite heavily scented which can trigger a reaction, and the white proraso contains a decent bit of menthol.
Anything with almond or cinnamon is also a common cause of issues, soaps such as Cella, Figaro etc.. Figaro will turn my skin red in about 30 seconds and isn't that great of a soap really.
Try not washing your face with any soap before shaving, and don't be too heavy handed with the brush. A good sharp blade is essential for me, something like a feather or a shark.
I too can recommend the Truefitt and Hill Ultimate Comfort shaving cream. No irritation whatsoever when using this coupled with the ASBTruefitt & Hill Ultimate Comfort shaving cream and matching ASB is my top cream. Nivea Sensitive cream and matching ASB is a close second. Both excellent for the skin.
Avocado is good but Truefitt Ultimate Comfort is better IMHOMost soothing and gentle I've ever tried (disclosure: I have not tried any of the unscented, and the Truefitt Ultimate Comfort is supposedly fantastic) is the TOBS Avocado. The scent is not bad, but took me maybe 3 shaves to really warm up to, now I absolutely love it. It does contain avocado oil Persea Gratissima (Avocado) Oil | Cosmetics Info which is great for skin.
Avocado is good but Truefitt Ultimate Comfort is better IMHO
This ^ ^ ^When I absolutely need a 100% irritation free shave I go with proraso white for sensitive skin.