A hard choice, there really isn’t must comparison to be had, but I’d put AOS on top scent-wise as well. TOBS and Proraso, well is probably put Proraso first since it’s more woody. But for performance I think TOBS cream hits just above Proraso, probably even over AOS.
Performance wise, I think I put them in the same order as my scent preferences. I think AOS is just a tad slicker than TOBS, and TOBS just a tad slicker than Proraso. But as we all know in this hobby, YMMV.