I've wet shaved on and off for years. used a brush and soap years ago but stopped and then came back to this when I picked up DE shaving again. I used Williams soap years ago. It was "ok" and I figure that my lathering technique probably needed some work back then. I haven't tried it since and have been using MWF and Coates. I see the comments here and there about Williams. comments about the old bars, new bars and comments about whether is lathers or not. Instead of going out and buying a puck of Williams to try all over again I thought I'd ask what it is about Williams that people hate or love that gets it so many curious comments.