Looking for a "Green" scent soap

[Golden_Edge]

I've been looking for a soap with Eucalyptus and/or Pine and/or Cedar and/or "Green"/"Forest".

Without menthol and not cologne like.

If SV has something in that range, even better since I am looking to buy a first one. Dolomiti was recommended by a member here in another post.

I liked C.O. Bigelow a lot (aka repackaged Green Proraso) but it's a cream and it's got menthol.

Fitjar Islands, Kaliflower and Lauger seem to have scents aligned with what I am looking for but I'd prefer something more accessible - I am US based.

Stirling appears to have "Green" scents. Any feedback is welcome.

 

[snowman]

I've been looking for a soap with Eucalyptus and/or Pine and/or Cedar and/or "Green"/"Forest" without menthol.

If SV has something in that range, even better since I am looking to buy a first one. If not, I am open to others.

I liked C.O. Bigelow a lot (aka repackaged Green Proraso) but it's a cream and it's got menthol.

Fitjar Islands, Kaliflower and Lauger seem to have scents aligned with what I am looking for but I'd prefer something more accessible - I am US based.

Stirling appears to have "Green" scents. Any feedback is welcome.

Mikes Pine and Cedarwood is excellent. No menthol, the scent is straight forward pine and cedar.

 

[Golden_Edge]

Mikes Pine and Cedarwood is excellent. No menthol, the scent is straight forward pine and cedar.

That's an excellent recommend, thank you. I can only imagine how good it must be (outstanding performance and scents) but being "out of stock" most of the time, I didn't even consider it (as in doesn't exist).

 

[Feldgrun]

I'd recommend The Sudsy Soapery Pine & Cedar. Also Lothur Oregon, but it's a bit like tree cologne. Both are excellent soaps.

 

[T Bone]

Southern Witchcrafts - Carpathia. Smells like an evergreen forest, with a bit of herbs and earthiness. But mostly those evergreens.

 

[Steve56]

Stirling Green!
Stirling Eucalyptus mint
Sanra Maria Novella

 

[kaufdrop27]

Stirling Scott’s Pine Sheep
Stirling Varen
They have several others that may work

 

[Hannah's Dad]

Varen is a brilliantly green fougere.

 

[Ravenonrock]

Thumbs up for Stirling Varen
Savon De Rasage O’ Vert (cut grass)
Shannons Soaps Haymarket Vetiver
MdC Original

 

[Heron]

Declaration Vernal is a green scent

 

[Pedigree]

I'd highly recommend MdC Fougere for a "green" scent. It is VERY green!

 

[Golden_Edge]

Thanks gents, many great recommendations.

The Sudsy Soapery and Santa Maria Novella unfortunately have menthol.

MdC is an excellent choice. I bought all scents from Maggard as samplers a while backbut couldn't take advantage of its full potential (difficulty lathering from such a small ). I remember the scents to be excellent. I'll revisit.

Stirling's offerings are appealing, especially considering the brand's well regarded performance. Scott’s Pine Sheep, Varen, Coniferous and Ozark Mountain.

Cheers all

 

[AlphaFrank75]

I just pulled out my tub of Varen for tomorrow's shave and when I took a big whiff, I thought about this thread. So yeah, Varen is a really deep, green scent.

 

[borwish]

Captain's Choice has a Eucalyptus scent.

This morning I used Razorock Green Label which is a woody/aromatic scent/

 

[lasta]

Nobody mentioned Proraso Green yet? I assume you have this already?

 

[CJB3]

Varen is a brilliantly green fougere.

My thoughts exactly. Stirling Varen is a mossy green forest.

 

[Barbarian80]

B&M Taiga is spot on cedar/pine/juniper forest. I dont think it's heavy but i wouldn't use it in the warmer months.

Varen is also a great one

 

[silverlifter]

Alpine forest, not cologne-like. Unique.

Speick stick

• silverlifter
• Jan 18, 2022

 

[Guido75]

The Goodfellas Smile Pino Alpestre might be worth looking into. Lathers easily and thoroughly with a good post shave feel. And has that fresh forestry pine tree scent to it. Not mentholated as far as I can tell.

Guido

 

[Time Bandit]

I've seen a lot of really good suggestions here but no one has mentioned Mousee Illuminee from Zingari Man.

It's a beautiful "green" fougere. I dare anyone with even a small bit of love for "green" scents to try it and tell me they don't live it. It is absolutely worth ever penny of is cost.

As others have said. I also agree that Stirling has more then a few good green options. So explore those too.