Out of curiosity, do you face lather or bowl lather?not a bad idea, thanks for the suggestion. I will try to just add enough cream for one pass each pass.
Asking, as it might be easier to bowl lather to reach that ideal consistency. I'm not sure how to explain it, but when the lather has that sheen, then you know it's the right proportion of water and soap. And yes, it does take some time to build it. But then, that's all the fun. Perhaps, with more "feel" for it, you can then face-lather, if you so prefer.