For me, I don't like the performance of most shave balms as much as I like the splashes. I've tried most store bought balms, and none seemed to do the trick, and several caused rashes. I do have some Captain's Choice Bay Rum balm, and while it works well, I don't see it doing as well as the Cat o' 9 Tails. Chiseled Face Sherlock splash works the best, but I like the Co9T scent way, way better, and it's performance is great.