AOS non-tallow formula? SAY IT AIN"T SO!

[global_dev]

i doubt the guys using the chrome plated plastic mach 3/fusions will even notice. it might even be better qualities for using a multiblade, not too thick for getting caught up with lather/hair and lasts long enough for the quick swipes of the carts.

i felt silly for stocking up on AOS during teh last sale. maybe not so much now.

 

[TallyShave]

Interesting how Proraso's reformulation was met with glee long before anyone even had a clue how it would turn out (I don't think it was an improvement). AOS, not so much. I really hope this change doesn't decrease the performance of one of the best soaps out there, but will wait to see before making a judgment.

 

[jkh]

Interesting how Proraso's reformulation was met with glee long before anyone even had a clue how it would turn out (I don't think it was an improvement). AOS, not so much. I really hope this change doesn't decrease the performance of one of the best soaps out there, but will wait to see before making a judgment.

Well, AoS is pulling the beloved and fabled tallow from the list. I am not sure there has ever reformulation of a shave soap in which tallow was removed and the masses thought the performance of the soap was improved. Please note, I do not consider tallow a
magic or required ingredient for an excellent performing shaving soap. Proraso removed parabens from the equation, which a fair number of folks would rather not have in in a shaving cream. Also, Proraso added other scent options to the line up, this was a big plus for a large number of customers.

That said, I agree - we shouldn't pass judgement on the AoS reformulation until there is more data.

 

[sgtd]

I've never tried their soaps because I always thought they were too expensive. Looks like I may have missed out.

 

[petr]

I'm going to pour a stiff drink and cry over this one. Seriously.

 

[oldtrout]

You know, one finds a fantastic soap and then invariably it is discontinued or reformulated. Such is our lot.

 

[Shave_Rat]

You know, one finds a fantastic soap and then invariably it is discontinued or reformulated. Such is our lot.

And yet, Caswell-Massey still makes shaving soap, and won't seem to stop. Oh, the irony.

 

[5savages]

There's still lots of tallow stock out there probably. When it's exhausted (which will probably be awhile), you can either not buy the new soap. or mill a refill together with a Valobra stick in a bowl, problem solved.

I'm not sure that's the case. Folks have been reporting that they've found AoS soap at TJ Maxx, which would make sense in light of this reformulation.

 

[stryker4526]

Interesting how Proraso's reformulation was met with glee long before anyone even had a clue how it would turn out (I don't think it was an improvement). AOS, not so much. I really hope this change doesn't decrease the performance of one of the best soaps out there, but will wait to see before making a judgment.

Well Proraso was reformulating to remove EVIL, NASTY CANCER and AoS is reformulating to remove angelic tallow, so it's not surprising that the reactions are opposite.

 

[lostinwv]

You guys might be interested to know that Lee's Safety Razors (leesrazors.com) has made in Italy/tallow stock of AOS soap. I just ordered a refill of unscented, which he has 8 more of. Lemon he has just a few of, in the bowl. He has a few lavender refills too. I can't remember what Lee told me about his stock of Sandlewood.

Dave

 

[Gingerbread]

Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

 

[Obsessed]

The end is nigh, that is some bad,bad news my friends. That is a palm oil based soap.

Hey, Jim, moderator question for you: just how many curse words can I put into a post without getting banned? Let me know. Thanks.

 

[Jim]

Hey, Jim, moderator question for you: just how many curse words can I put into a post without getting banned? Let me know. Thanks.

In this case it may be Pi.

 

[Marco]

AoS soaps made in USA?

 

[Obsessed]

AoS soaps made in USA?

I guess Proctor & Gamble figures it doesn't make sense for them to outsource their soap making when they actually manufacture soap themselves.

 

[Kramerica]

All I know is that the day M&W announces a reformulation of Tabac is the day to finally storm the castle.

Sad news indeed.

 

[auk1124]

Hey everyone, relax. Maybe AOS is now sourcing its soap from the US factory that makes modern Williams.

 

[Unadan]

I'm non-plussed by this because I prefer their creams.

 

[TonyJoe]

Hey everyone, relax. Maybe AOS is now sourcing its soap from the US factory that makes modern Williams.

Dude! I was just going to post something about how ironic it might be if their new contract was with Combe. But then why contract anyone? P&G makes Ivory, right?

 

[TonyJoe]

All I know is that the day M&W announces a reformulation of Tabac is the day to finally storm the castle.

Sad news indeed.

Agree.